Suggestions by @horrorobsessed
419 suggestions
Lindsay Hollister
as Fanny in The Auctioneer
Esmé Bianco
as Virginia Guthrie in The House Next Door
Judy Pace
as Odessa Redd in The Elementals
Emmy Rossum
as Mariana Andros in The Maidens
Richard Madden
as Duncan Phair in Gilded Needles
Sean Astin
as Rev. Edward Stallworth in Gilded Needles
Lara Jean Chorostecki
as Agnes Cogswell in The Auctioneer
Mark Donovan
as Gilg in Plaguewalker
Bernadette Peters
as Gerta in Plaguewalker
Lance Henriksen
as Old Sam Perry in The Auctioneer
Joshua Leonard
as Mickey Cogswell in The Auctioneer
Charlayne Woodard
as Odessa Redd in The Elementals
Gillian Jacobs
as Leigh Savage in The Elementals
Hettienne Park
as Jessica Landis in Fantasticland
Joseph Quinn
as Deputy Harlan in William Gay’s Twilight
Caroline Dhavernas
as Mim Moore in The Auctioneer
Austin Abrams
as Chase Pounder in Fantasticland
Henry Zebrowski
as Ernie Owens in Dead and Buried
Devon Weetly
as Sam McVey in Fantasticland
Jaheem Toombs
as Sam McVey in Fantasticland