Suggestions by @horrorobsessed

Kristen Lee Gutoskie

as Eloise Jennings in The House Next Door

Morgan Davies

as Kenneth Tyler in William Gay’s Twilight

Samantha Sloyan

as Fredericka in The September House

Katharine Isabelle

as T.C. Moore in Kill Creek

Denis O'Hare

as James Caskey in Blackwater

Frances McDormand

as Mary-Love Caskey in Blackwater

Judah Lewis

as George LeMoyne / ‘Freddie LaVall’ in Dead and Buried

Judah Lewis

as Brock Hockney in Fantasticland

Bobby Moynihan

as Sam Garliek in Fantasticland

Ethan Cutkosky

as Jason Card in Fantasticland

Tobin Bell

as Judge James Stallworth in Gilded Needles

Madison Iseman

as Jill Van Meveran in Fantasticland

Josh Brolin

as Agamemnon in The Song of Achilles

Iain Glen

as Priam in The Song of Achilles

Joel Marsh Garland

as Sheriff Bob Gore in The Auctioneer

Morgan Taylor Campbell

as Andromache in The Song of Achilles

Grace Zabriskie

as Ginny in Pretty Girls

Jake Weber

as Phil Mueller in Fantasticland

Pablo Schreiber

as Sheriff Dan Gillis in Dead and Buried

Cameron Monaghan

as Simeon Lightener in Gilded Needles