Suggestions by @alexanderarmstrong
4,546 suggestions
James Jude Courtney
as Jack O Lantern in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Tyler Mane
as Jack O Lantern in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Michael Kayne
as Jack O Lantern in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Anthony Anderson
as Doctor Buffy in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Rand Gamble
as Craig in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Robbie Amell
as Evan Landers in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Dagmara Dominczyk
as Chassity Brandan in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Lexa Doig
as Bennett Dally in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Erin Micklow
as Maisie Runder in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Roxanne Perez
as Sheriff Sarah in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Gideon Adlon
as Debbie Willer in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Maisy Stella
as Aileen Vamos in The Jack-O-Lanterns
David Schwimmer
as Justin Ramso in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Iris Apatow
as Debra Darling in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Hunter Doohan
as Leander Dubston in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Kaniehtiio Horn
as Katie Davids in The Jack-O-Lanterns
Ray Nicholson
as Ridley Richmond in Dead Man Slaying
Kaniehtiio Horn
as Seedie Macey in THE SODA GLOB
Patrick Warburton
as Andy Rodgers in THE SODA GLOB
Christina Ricci
as Kathryn Freeman in Night Of The Chainsaws