Suggestions by @alexanderarmstrong

Maxwell Jacob Friedman

as Valerian Schneebly in The Jack-O-Lanterns

Alexandra Shipp

as Ellie Grendolph in The Jack-O-Lanterns

Mickie James

as CowGirl Mindy Cutler in Scared Shitless

Jean-Claude Van Damme

as Brycent Giles in Scared Shitless

Eminem

as Mayor Emory Holzter in The Jack-O-Lanterns

Seth Rogen

as Executive Producer in Scared Shitless

AlexanderD.

as Director in Scared Shitless

AlexanderD.

as Writer in Scared Shitless

AlexanderD.

as Vulgar Narrator in Scared Shitless

O'Shea Jackson Jr.

as Sheridan Hoff in Scared Shitless

Sydney Park

as Sadie Mucci in Scared Shitless

Kaitlin Olson

as Marley O'Donnell in Scared Shitless

Seth Green

as Devon Dunkson in Scared Shitless

Olivia Rodrigo

as Maggie Stewart in Scared Shitless

Seth Rogen

as Paul Wydona in Scared Shitless

Doug Jones

as Jack O Lantern in The Jack-O-Lanterns

Lionsgate Films

as Producer in The Jack-O-Lanterns

AlexanderD.

as Writer in The Jack-O-Lanterns

AlexanderD.

as Director in The Jack-O-Lanterns

Derek Mears

as Jack O Lantern in The Jack-O-Lanterns