Suggestions by @wickedtheatrefan

Diana DeGarmo

as Penny Pingleton in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Kerry Butler

as Penny Pingleton in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Laura Bell Bundy

as Amber Von Tussle in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Dove Cameron

as Amber Von Tussle in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Brittney Johnson

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Kara Lindsay

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Annaleigh Ashford

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Alli Mauzey

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Kate Reinders

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Megan Hilty

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Laura Bell Bundy

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Kristin Chenoweth

as Glinda in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Mary Kate Morrissey

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Jessica Vosk

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Lilli Cooper

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Lindsay Mendez

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Mandy Gonzalez

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Kerry Ellis

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Stephanie J. Block

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Caissie Levy

as Elphaba in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?