Suggestions by @whitewolf
276 suggestions
Doug Jones
as Tinkering Clown in Batman Triumphant

Anna Katarina
as Poodle Lady in Batman Triumphant

Rene Auberjonois
as Dr Maxwell Burton in Batman Triumphant

Elizabeth Sanders
as Gossip Gerty in Batman Triumphant

Pat Hingle
as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman Triumphant

Michael Gough
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Triumphant
Chris O'Donnell
as Robin/Nightwing in Batman Triumphant

Jennifer Lopez
as Det. Renee Montoya in Batman Triumphant

Madonna
as Harley Quinn in Batman Triumphant
Alicia Silverstone
as Batgirl in Batman Triumphant

Steve Buscemi
as Scarecrow in Batman Triumphant
George Clooney
as Batman in Batman Triumphant
John Goodman
as Harvey Bullock in Batman Unchained (2000)
Keke Palmer
as Toadette in The Super Mario Movie
Jonah Hill
as Diddy Kong in The Super Mario Movie
Bobby Cannavale
as Waluigi in The Super Mario Movie