Suggestions by @user_214973

Lauren LaVera

as Shelly Webster in The Crow (2024 Reboot Series)

Joe Keery

as Christopher Hartley in Until Dawn

Dylan O'Brien

as Mike Munroe in Until Dawn

Florence Pugh

as Samantha Giddings in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua in Until Dawn

Florence Pugh

as Sam Giddings in Until Dawn (2024)

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Dylan O'Brien

as Michael Munroe in Until Dawn

Israel Broussard

as Joshua Washington in Until Dawn

Kyle Gallner

as Josh in Until Dawn (2005)

Israel Broussard

as Josh in Until Dawn

Kyle Gallner

as Josh Washington in Until Dawn (2005)

Lily Reinhart

as Jess in Until Dawn

Thomasin McKenzie

as Hannah in Until Dawn

Katie Douglas

as Beth in Until Dawn

Bill Skarsgård

as Harry Osborn in MCU Spider-Man Villain and Ally Fancast