Suggestions by @tylercruz
1,796 suggestions

Neil Patrick Harris
as Music Meister in Gotham Knights
Luis Guzmán
as Penny Plunderer in Gotham Knights

Amy Adams
as Calendar girl in Gotham Knights

Paloma Faith
as Calendar girl in Gotham Knights

Mark Ruffalo
as Amadeus Arkham in Gotham Knights

Debby Ryan
as Magpie in Gotham Knights

Armie Hammer
as Ten-Eyed Man in Gotham Knights

Hannah Waddingham
as Jane Doe in Gotham Knights
Roselyn Sánchez
as Catwoman in Gotham Knights

Meryl Streep
as Anchoress in Gotham Knights
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
as Cavalier in Gotham Knights

Johnny Depp
as Cavalier in Gotham Knights
Bill Hader
as Crazy Quilt in Gotham Knights
Kathy Bates
as Ma Parker in Gotham Knights

Justina Machado
as La llorona in Gotham Knights
Roselyn Sánchez
as La llorona in Gotham Knights

Rosie Perez
as La llorona in Gotham Knights

Matthew Lillard
as Calendar man in Gotham Knights

Mathew Lilliard
as Calendar man in Gotham Knights
Michael Emerson
as Ventriloquist in Gotham Knights