Suggestions by @tullybrekker

Elizabeth Mitchell

as Lydia in Confess

Danielle Rose Russell

as Auburn Reed in Confess

Ted Sutherland

as Sagan in Without Merit

Mena Massoud

as Sagan in Without Merit

Timothée Chalamet

as Sagan in Without Merit

Amy Adams

as Victoria Voss in Without Merit

Jacob Tremblay

as Moby in Without Merit

Steve Zahn

as Father Voss in Without Merit

Brittany O'Grady

as Angela in Without Merit

Tom Holland

as Utah in Without Merit

Fred Hechinger

as Luck in Without Merit

Fred Hechinger

as Utah in Without Merit

Samara Weaving

as Victoria in Without Merit

Chiara Aurelia

as Honor Voss in Without Merit

Chiara Aurelia

as Merit Voss in Without Merit

Olivia Holt

as Meshell Mermaid in Ever After High

Skai Jackson

as Nina Thumbell in Ever After High

Emily Alyn Lind

as Crystal Winter in Ever After High

Han Seung-yeon

as Melody Piper in Ever After High

Booboo Stewart

as Chase Redford in Ever After High