Suggestions by @timemachine
8,246 suggestions
Rosario Dawson
as Melissa Foreman-Greenwald in Big Mouth (90s Teen Cast)
Alicia Witt
as Jessica Cobain Glaser in Big Mouth (90s Teen Cast)
Ricki Lake
as Sara in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
Anthony Kramreither Jr.
as Chip Manhands in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
BD Wong
as Larry in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
Lisa Bonet
as Francis in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
Renee Murphy
as Merian in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
Nena Rosier
as Pliny in StuGo (80s Teen Cast)
Rick Schroder
as Will Sinclair Dennis in We Were Liars ('80s)
JoBeth Williams
as Tipper Sinclair in We Were Liars ('80s)
Heather O'Rourke
as Liberty Sinclair Sheffield in We Were Liars ('80s)
Heather O'Rourke
as Bonnie Sinclair Sheffield in We Were Liars ('80s)
Donna Mills
as Bess Sinclair Sheffield in We Were Liars ('80s)
Jane Fonda
as Carrie Sinclair Dennis in We Were Liars ('80s)
Jessica Lange
as Penny Sinclair Eastman in We Were Liars ('80s)
Elisabeth Shue
as Mirren Sinclair Sheffield in We Were Liars ('80s)
Christopher Atkins
as Jonathan Sinclair Dennis in We Were Liars ('80s)
Rajiv Kapoor
as Gatwick Matthew Patil in We Were Liars ('80s)
Olivia D'Abo
as Cadence Sinclair Eastman in We Were Liars ('80s)
Courtney Ramirez (My Super Sweet Psycho 16)
as America Ferrera in Which characters would you like to see actors play in the mid-2000s?