Suggestions by @themegacaster

Nick Frost

as Detective Chimp in Monster Squad: Polybius

Olga Kurylenko

as The Bride in Monster Squad: Polybius

Mark Hamill

as G. I Robot in Monster Squad: Polybius

Charlie Cox

as Frankenstein in Monster Squad: Polybius

Anthony Mackie

as Nick Fury Jr. in Monster Squad: Polybius

Tom Hardy

as Abraham Van Helsing in Monster Squad: Polybius

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Maria Hill in Monster Squad: Polybius

David Dastmalchian

as Morbius The Living Vampire in Monster Squad: Polybius

Emma Corrin

as Enchantress in Monster Squad: Polybius

Tommy Lee Jones

as Nick Fury Sr. in Monster Squad: Polybius

Andy Samberg

as Phil Coulson in Monster Squad: Polybius

Jessie Buckley

as Elsa Bloodstone in Monster Squad: Polybius

Jack Black

as The Big Bad Wolf in Monster Squad: Polybius

Ashley Walters

as Blade in Monster Squad: Polybius

Jorma Taccone

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World

Pyro (Team Fortress)

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World

Devon Bostick

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World

Scout

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World

Steve Zahn

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World

Engineer

as “Waller’s New Recruits” in Super Mario World