Suggestions by @themaniax

Ally Sheedy

as Michelle in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

Kelly McGillis

as Barbara Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

John Thaw

as Alfred Pennyworth in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

John Saxon

as James Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

Molly Ringwald

as Carrie Kelley in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

Clint Eastwood

as Bruce Wayne in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 (1986)

Tim Burton

as Writer in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Wes Craven

as Director in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Craig Safan

as Composer in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Elisabeth Shue

as Gwen Stacy in The Amazing Spider-Man (1986)

Robert Englund

as The Joker in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Johnathan Pryce

as Edward Nygma in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Jeffrey Combs

as Edward Nygma in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Selina Kyle in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Ally Sheedy

as Michelle in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Ron Perlman

as Mutant Leader in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Kelly McGillis

as Barbara Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Christine Elise

as Barbara Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

John Saxon

as James Gordon in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)

Johnny Depp

as Dick Grayson in The Dark Knight Returns Part 1 (1985)