Suggestions by @thechaser87

Josh Stewart

as Trevor Lyle in Candyman

Lily Rabe

as Helen Lyle in Candyman

Willem Dafoe

as Edward Nygma in Batman (1980's)

Brad Dourif

as The Joker in Batman (1980's)

David Warner

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman (1980's)

Sean Connery

as Ra's Al Ghul in Batman (1980's)

Geena Davis

as Selina Kyle in Batman (1980's)

André Gower

as Robin in Batman (1980's)

Ellen Burstyn

as Martha Wayne in Batman (1980's)

James Stewart

as Thomas Wayne in Batman (1980's)

Jeffrey Combs

as Jonathan Crane in Batman (1980's)

Alec Baldwin

as Harvey Dent in Batman (1980's)

Richard Roundtree

as Lucius Fox in Batman (1980's)

Robert Redford

as Commissioner Gordon in Batman (1980's)

Bob Hoskins

as Oswald Cobblepot in Batman (1980's)

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Talia Al Ghul in Batman (1980's)

Richard Gere

as Bruce Wayne in Batman (1980's)

Joel Edgerton

as Bernhard Baker in Animal Man

Geena Davis

as Billie Dean Howard in American Horror Story: Murder House (1980s)

Katherine Hepburn

as Constance Langdon in American Horror Story: Murder House (1980s)