Suggestions by @the_critic_ruben_jr

Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Poison Ivy

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

She-Hulk (Jennifer Walters)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Shadowcat (Kitty Pryde)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Rogue

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Lydia Deetz

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Catwoman (Selina Kyle)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Veruca Salt

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Violet Beauregarde

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

She-Venom (Anne Weying)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Ava Ayala (White Tiger)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Spider-Girl (Mayday Parker)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Zatanna Zatara

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Dorothy Gale

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Alice Liddell

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Velma Dinkley

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Raven (Rachel Roth)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Esther Coleman

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Emily (Corpse Bride)

as Jenna Ortega in What if this actor played

Harry Osborn

as Timothée Chalamet in What if this actor played