Suggestions by @tanyamalik

Carly Chaikin

as Elsa Fitz in Pretty Little Liars (if it was made today also doing gender-bent characters)

Angela Bassett

as Ana Spanikopita in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Jennifer Carpenter

as Kelsey Jannings in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Noah Centineo

as Todd Chavez in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Sivan Alyra Rose

as Hayley Pace in Final Girls

Reese Witherspoon

as Lisa in Final Girls

January Jones

as Lisa in Final Girls

Alexander Skarsgård

as Coop in Final Girls

Sasha Pieterse

as Quincy in Final Girls

Kirsten Vangsness

as Wanda Pierce in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Abigail Breslin

as Stefani Stilton in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Mia Zottoli

as Stefani Stilton in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Barbie Ferreira

as Hollyhock in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Ariana Grande

as Pickles Aplenty in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Jun Ji-hyun

as Diane Nguyen in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Arden Cho

as Diane Nguyen in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Kathryn Newton

as Leeloo in The Fifth Element (Reboot)

Jodie Comer

as Quincy in Final Girls

Rome Flynn

as Craig in Final Girls

Kerry Ingram

as Amy in Final Girls