Suggestions by @tanyamalik

Allen Leech

as Jeff in Final Girls

Carly Chaikin

as Sarah Sanderson in Hocus Pocus

Topher Grace

as Flip McVicker in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Zoe Saldaña

as Gina Cazador in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Stephanie Beatriz

as Gina Cazador in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Neil Patrick Harris

as Mr. Peanut Butter in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Hannah Marks

as Pheobe Buffay in Friends

Martin Wallström

as Ross Geller in Friends

Millie Bobby Brown

as River Tam in Firefly (Reboot)

Kerry Ingram

as River Tam in Firefly (Reboot)

Shay Mitchell

as Inara Serra in Firefly (Reboot)

Kathryn Newton

as Kaywinnet Lee Frye in Firefly (Reboot)

Shah Rukh Khan

as Bojack Horseman in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Zoey Deutch

as Stefani Stilton in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Anna Faris

as Princess Carolyn in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Gideon Adlon

as Penny in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Olivia DeJonge

as Hollyhock in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Madison Davenport

as Mia Valentine in The Loved Ones

Leslie Grossman

as Princess Carolyn in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Doona Bae

as Diane Nguyen in Live Action Bojack Horseman