Suggestions by @talalagirlg46

John C. Reilly

as 2000s in What Actors Would've Played PepperMan from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Tisha Campbell

as Original Doisette in Pizza Tower (1990s Live Action)

Jim Carrey

as Pizzahead in Pizza Tower (1990s Live Action)

Doug Jones

as Fake Peppino (Dyed hair black) in Pizza Tower (1990s Live Action)

Ed Harris

as Vigilante/Lante (Dyed hair light yellow) in Pizza Tower (1990s Live Action)

J.K. Simmons

as Mr Stick in Pizza Tower (1990s Live Action)

Doug Jones

as 2010s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Taika Waititi

as 2020s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Taika Waititi

as 2010s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Will Ferrell

as 2010s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Will Ferrell

as 2000s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Will Ferrell

as 1990s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Doug Jones

as 2000s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Doug Jones

as 1990s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Doug Jones

as 1980s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Harvey Korman

as 1960s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Harvey Korman

as 1970s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Red Skelton

as 1950s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Fred MacMurray

as 1940s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades

Red Skelton

as 1940s in What Actors Would've Played Fake Peppino from Pizza Tower in Various Decades