Suggestions by @summertime6

Matthew Daddario

as Gareth Tempa in Ruthless Boys of the Zodiac

Stephen James

as Darius Acrux in Zodiac Academy

Madelyn Cline

as Bex in First Down

Grant Gustin

as Cooper in First Down

Noah Centineo

as James in First Down

Willa Holland

as Jordan Carrington in Paper Princess

Sydney Sweeney

as Savannah Montgomery in Paper Princess

Cooper van Grootel

as Seth in Zodiac Academy

Rudy Pankow

as Caleb in Zodiac Academy

Melissa Collazo

as Valérie carrington in Paper Princess

Dylan Sprouse

as Sebastian Royal in Paper Princess

Cole Sprouse

as Sawyer Royal in Paper Princess

Emma Roberts

as Ella harper in Paper Princess

Claire Holt

as Brooke in Paper Princess

Cody Christian

as Easton Royal in Paper Princess

Ian Somerhalder

as Gideon Royal in Paper Princess

Margot Robbie

as Melinda Altair in Zodiac Academy

Lucas Till

as Tyler in Zodiac Academy

Noah Centineo

as Xavier in Zodiac Academy

Sophia Carson

as Darcy Vega in Zodiac Academy