Suggestions by @stevodavies

Kyle Gallner

as Spalding in American Horror Story Recast

Jack Quaid

as Kyle Spencer in American Horror Story Recast

Milla Jovovich

as Charlotte Brown in American Horror Story Recast

Toby Kebbell

as Spivey in American Horror Story Recast

Elizabeth Moss

as Mother Claudia in American Horror Story Recast

Maya Hawke

as Wendy Peyser in American Horror Story Recast

Salma Hayek

as Shachath in American Horror Story Recast

Madison Bailey

as Alma Walker in American Horror Story Recast

mgk

as Leo Morrison in American Horror Story Recast

Cailee Spaeny

as Pepper in American Horror Story Recast

Emilia Clarke

as Leigh Emerson in American Horror Story Recast

Jena Malone

as Shelley in American Horror Story Recast

Mena Suvari

as Sister Jude in American Horror Story Recast

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Sister Mary Eunice in American Horror Story Recast

Timothy Chalamet

as Kit Walker in American Horror Story Recast

Mia Goth

as Lana Winters in American Horror Story Recast

Chris Hemsworth

as Phil Critter in American Horror Story Recast

Florence Pugh

as Elizabeth Short in American Horror Story Recast

Johnny Depp

as Hugo Langdon in American Horror Story Recast

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Abby in American Horror Story Recast