Suggestions by @squishywizard

Dacre Montgomery

as Jack Wilder in Now You See Me (2023)

Matthew McConaughey

as Merritt McKinney in Now You See Me (2023)

Samuel L. Jackson

as Thaddeus Bradley in Now You See Me (2023)

Millicent Simmonds

as Charlie Graham in Hereditary

Hayden Panettiere

as Bobby-Lynne Parker in X

Malin Åkerman

as Judy Hicks in The Scream Requels

Winona Ryder

as Sidney Prescott in The Scream Requels

Lyrica Okano

as Anika Kayoko in The Scream Requels

Noah Schnapp

as Ethan Landry in The Scream Requels

Jacob Dudman

as Wes Hicks in The Scream Requels

Rachel Zegler

as Tara Carpenter in The Scream Requels

Zendaya

as Mindy Meeks-Martin in The Scream Requels

Amanda Seyfried

as Kirby Reed in The Scream Requels

Allison Tolman

as Martha Meeks in The Scream Requels

Michael Evans Behling

as Chad Meeks-Martin in The Scream Requels

Christian Serratos

as Sam Carpenter in The Scream Requels

Paul Rudd

as Dewey Riley in The Scream Requels

Marisa Tomei

as Gale Weathers in The Scream Requels

Jason Isaacs

as Christopher Stone in The Scream Requels

Melissa Benoist

as Laura Crane in The Scream Requels