Suggestions by @silverangvantibo

Sonja Richter

as Elise Wærenskjold in Nantucket

Scoot McNairy

as Marcus Peleg in Nantucket

David Gyasi

as Daggoo in Nantucket

Walton Goggins

as Peleg's Captain in Nantucket

Spoiler

as Peleg's Captain in Nantucket

Charlie Cox

as The Traveler in Nantucket

Spoiler

as The Traveler in Nantucket

Scott Handy

as Elijah in Nantucket

Damon Herriman

as Dirck Boggart in Nantucket

Jimmi Simpson

as Stabb in Nantucket

Jamie Dornan

as Starbuck in Nantucket

Peter Vack

as Arthur Gordon in Nantucket

Eleanor Tomlinson

as Mrs. Mary Hassey in Nantucket

Max Martini

as John Rutherford in Nantucket

Christian Rubeck

as Svend Foyn in Nantucket

Te Kohe Tuhaka

as Queequeg in Nantucket

Yadira Guevara-Prip

as Kanina Beatherskin in The Strange One

Hugh Jackman

as Darth Revan in Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

Evan Roderick

as Captain Carrot in Discworld

Emily Watson

as Mary McDonald in The Strange One