Suggestions by @silmarils
435 suggestions

David Anders
as Victor Zsasz in Robins
+3-1Score: +2

Stephen Fry
as Professor Pyg in Robins
+4-2Score: +2
John Noble
as Ventriloquist in Robins
+3-2Score: +1
Andy Serkis
as Mad Hatter in Robins
+3-2Score: +1

Kelsey Grammer
as Hugo Strange in Robins
+1-2Score: -1

Eric Bana
as Hush in Robins
+1-0Score: +1

Bradley Cooper
as Clayface in Robins
+1-3Score: -2
Elijah Wood
as Jonathan Crane in Robins
+5-5Score: 0

Stanley Tucci
as Victor Fries in Robins
+2-4Score: -2
Hugh Laurie
as Edward Nygma in Robins
+2-3Score: -1
Ewan McGregor
as Two-Face in Robins
+1-2Score: -1

Salma Hayek
as Selina Kyle in Robins
+6-12Score: -6
Alexander Siddig
as Rha's Al Ghul in Robins
+5-5Score: 0

Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje
as Killer Croc in Robins
+11-1Score: +10

Eva Green
as Talia Al Ghul in Robins
+7-13Score: -6

Ronda Rousey
as Batgirl in Robins
+1-10Score: -9

John Boyega
as Batwing in Robins
+10-1Score: +9

Michael Madsen
as Harvey Bullock in Robins
+7-2Score: +5

Emma Stone
as Oracle in Robins
+9-9Score: 0

William H. Macy
as James Gordon in Robins
+2-3Score: -1