Suggestions by @shining_solo

Reneé Rapp

as Zoey Chambers in Nightmare Time: Honey Queen

Paul Bettany

as Gerald Monroe in Nightmare Time: Honey Queen

Anthony Hopkins

as Linda's Father in Nightmare Time: Honey Queen

Kathryn Hahn

as Linda Monroe in Nightmare Time: Honey Queen

Sydney Sweeney

as Webby in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Kit Harington

as Judge in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Helena Bonham Carter

as Willabella Muckwab in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Nicole Kidman

as Miss Holloway in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Sean Astin

as Duke Keane in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Jessica Walter

as Pamela Foster in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Elliot Page

as Doug in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Erika Henningsen

as Greenpeace Girl in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Ramon Reed

as Tim Huston in Black Friday

Ramon Reed

as Tim Huston in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Jacob Tremblay

as Tim Huston in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Mike O'Malley

as Tony Green in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Joseph Quinn

as Ethan Green in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Dove Cameron

as Lex Foster in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Jenna Ortega

as Hannah Foster in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web

Melissa Benoist

as Jane Perkins in Nightmare Time: Jane's A Car/ A Witch in the Web