Suggestions by @sethzarandona

Morgan Freeman

as Elder of Heimdall in Tales of Symphonia

Ephraim Sykes

as Storyteller in Tales of Symphonia

George Takei

as Chief Igaguri in Tales of Symphonia

Masi Oka

as Tiga in Tales of Symphonia

Yoon San-ha

as Lamar in Godspell

Jin

as Lamar in Godspell

Lil Nas X

as Jeffrey in Godspell

Halle Bailey

as Peggy in Godspell

Alexa Medina

as Sonia in Godspell

Caleb McLaughlin

as Herb in Godspell

Joshua Bassett

as Lamar in Godspell

Jess Darrow

as Joanne in Godspell

Eliot Salt

as Gilmer in Godspell

Sofia Wylie

as Robin in Godspell

Mena Massoud

as John the Baptist/Judas in Godspell

Frankie Rodriguez

as Jesus in Godspell

Invisible Woman (Sue Storm)

as Action Girl in Sort by Tropes

Elektra Natchios

as Action Girl in Sort by Tropes

Utena Tenjou

as Action Girl in Sort by Tropes

Izzy Garcia/Dino Fury Green Ranger

as Action Girl in Sort by Tropes