Suggestions by @secretlyaciaunicorn

Rami Malek

as Ben Daimio in Hellboy TV show

Tessa Thompson

as Liz Sherman in Hellboy TV show

Tom Hardy

as Hellboy in Hellboy TV show

Oscar Isaac

as Mr. Boddy in CLUE

Naomie Harris

as Miss Scarlet in CLUE

David Harbour

as Col. Mustard in CLUE

Sam Neill

as Rev. Green in CLUE

Cate Blanchett

as Mrs. Peacock in CLUE

Ewan McGregor

as Prof. Plum in CLUE

Awkwafina

as Mrs. White in CLUE

Pedro Pascal

as Duke Senior in As You Like It

Idris Elba

as Jaques in As You Like It

James Corden

as Touchstone in As You Like It

Jude Law

as Oliver in As You Like It

Luke Evans

as Duke Fredrick in As You Like It

Emma Watson

as Celia in As You Like It

Saoirse Ronan

as Rosalind in As You Like It

Robert Pattinson

as Orlando in As You Like It

Thomas Newman

as Composer in Beetlejuice Reboot

Daisy Ridley

as Barbara Maitland in Beetlejuice