Suggestions by @ seangrant

Jeroen Krabbe

as Tak-Ne in Highlander Franchise

Alan Alda

as Tak-Ne in Highlander Franchise

James Remar

as Tak-Ne in Highlander Franchise

Christopher Walken

as Connor MacLeod in Highlander Franchise

Wesley Snipes

as Connor MacLeod in Highlander Franchise

Denzel Washington

as Mr. Fantastic in Characters for future MCU movies

+1-15Score: -14

George Clooney

as Mr. Fantastic in Characters for future MCU movies

+1-14Score: -13

Terry-Thomas

as Bonasera in Godfather (Alternative cast)

+2-0Score: +2

Sean Bean

as Randall Flagg in The Stand

Ben Affleck

as Stu Redman in The Stand

Kristen Stewart

as Frannie Goldsmith in The Stand

Sean Bean

as Randall Flagg in The Stand (2020)

+1-3Score: -2

Mariska Hargitay

as Lucy Swann in George A. Romero's The Stand (1990)

Lochlyn Munro

as A.j. Simon in Simon and Simon

+2-0Score: +2

James Remar

as Rick Simon in Simon and Simon

Jennifer Aniston

as Lieutenant Abigail Brown in Simon and Simon

Mariska Hargitay

as Lieutenant Abigail Brown in Simon and Simon

Denzel Washington

as Lieutenant Marcel Proust “Downtown” Brown in Simon and Simon

Richard Yniguez

as Rembrandt in The Warriors (alternative cast)