Suggestions by @saracuda

Mr. Tumnus

as Faun in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Gus (Sweet Tooth)

as Hybrid creatures in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Adam and Barbara Maitland

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Haunter

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Misdreavus

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Gastly

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Gengar

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Wisp (Animal Crossing)

as Ghost in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

K.K. Slider

as Dog in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Aragorn (Lord of the Rings)

as Human in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Loki (Loki Laufeyson)

as God/Goddess in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

God (Bruce Almighty)

as God/Goddess in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Buddy Hobbs

as Elf in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Angel (Buffyverse)

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Willow Rosenberg

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Marnie Piper

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Gillian Owens (Practical Magic)

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Sally Owens (Practical Magic)

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Sabrina Spellman

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Hermione Granger

as Witch in Sorting Fictional characters by Species