Suggestions by @samanthanew

Eva Noblezada

as Eurydice in Hadestown

Reeve Carney

as Orpheus in Hadestown

Eva Noblezada

as Persephone in Hadestown

Phoebe Dynevor

as Feyre in A Court of Thorns and Roses

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Lopen in The Way of Kings

Paul C. Grenier

as Riverwind in Dragonlance

Timothée Chalamet

as Szeth in The Way of Kings

Deborah Ann Woll

as Shallan Davar in The Way of Kings

Eleanor Tomlinson

as Shallan Davar in The Way of Kings

Rahul Kohli

as Bob the Skull in The Dresden Files

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Harry Dresden in The Dresden Files

Joel Kinnaman

as Harry Dresden in The Dresden Files

Max Greenfield

as Hermes in Hercules

Lisa Kudrow

as Aphrodite in Hercules

Blake Lively

as Aphrodite in Hercules

Billy Porter

as Hermes in Hercules

Jon Hamm

as Hades in Hercules

Andy Samberg

as Harry Dresden in The Dresden Files

Taylor Kitsch

as Harry Dresden in The Dresden Files

Colin Firth

as Breeze in Mistborn