Suggestions by @roryworthington

Nic Rouleau

as Agent Phil Coulson in Rogers: the Musical

Courtney B. Vance

as Nick Fury in Rogers: the Musical

Samantha Barks

as Peggy Carter in Rogers: the Musical

Jelani Alladin

as Sam Wilson in Rogers: the Musical

Krysta Rodriguez

as Natasha Romanoff in Rogers: the Musical

Isaac Powell

as Loki in Rogers: the Musical

Cheyenne Jackson

as Thor in Rogers: the Musical

Corey Cott

as Bucky Barnes in Rogers: the Musical

Darren Chris

as Bruce Banner in Rogers: the Musical

Jeremy Jordan

as Howard Stark in Rogers: the Musical

Jeremy Jordan

as Tony Stark in Rogers: the Musical