Suggestions by @rorysainsbury

Verne (Over the Hedge)

as Tobey Maguire in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Z (Antz)

as Tobey Maguire in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Adult Spike the Dragon

as Tobey Maguire in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Sonic the Hedgehog (Character)

as Tobey Maguire in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Max (The Secret Life of Pets)

as Tobey Maguire in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Hitchhiker (Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas)

as Tobey Maguire in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

Sam Cahill

as Tobey Maguire in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

Red Pollard

as Tobey Maguire in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

Red Pollard

as Tobey Maguire in Ranking Characters By Actor

Charlie Murphy

as Underrated Actors That Should Have Gotten Further In Their Careers in TomzillawasH3R3's Voting Pages

Derek Theler

as Chris Redfield in Resident Evil (Live Action Series)

Elijah Wood

as Chris Redfield in Resident Evil (Live Action Series)

Adam Garcia

as "Hoff Knows Talent" production assistant in Hop (2001)

Connor Bringas

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

Corey Bringas

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

David Moscow

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

Miko Hughes

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

Frankie Muniz

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

Elijah Wood

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as 1990's (Animation) in Which Actors Should've Played Spike in Various Decades?