Suggestions by @romarioharvey

Brandon Niederauer

as Jason (Seasons 1-3) (Inspired by Jason from Barney and the Backyard Gang) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Dallas Liu

as Adam (Seasons 1-2) (Guest: Season 3) (Inspired by Adam from the Backyard Gang) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Caitlin Sanchez

as Bianca (Season 1) (Guest: Season 2) (Inspired by Luci) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Brianna Gentilella

as Bianca (Season 1) (Guest: Season 2) (Inspired by Luci) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Alexandria Suarez

as Maya (Seasons 1-2) (Guest: Season 3) (Inspired by Tina) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Laurel Griggs

as Katie (Seasons 1-3) (Inspired by Kathy) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Skylar Gaertner

as Jay (Seasons 1-3) (Inspired by Shawn) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Tylen Jacob Williams

as Elijah (Seasons 1-2) (Guest: Season 3) (Inspired by Derek) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Caleb McLaughlin

as Elijah (Seasons 1-2) (Guest: Season 3) (Inspired by Derek) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Angie Wu

as Dalisay (Seasons 1-3) (inspired by Min) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Lola Tung

as Dalisay (Seasons 1-3) (inspired by Min) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

AC Bonifacio

as Dalisay (Seasons 1-3) (inspired by Min) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Meg Donnelly

as Abby (Seasons 1-2) (Guest: Season 3) (Inspired by Amy from the Backyard Gang) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Joseph John Schirle

as Brian (Seasons 1-2) (inspired by Michael) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Ethan Cutkosky

as Brian (Seasons 1-2) (inspired by Michael) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Charlie Plummer

as Brian (Seasons 1-2) (inspired by Michael) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Jacob Bertrand

as Brian (Seasons 1-2) (inspired by Michael) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Kyle Pacek

as BJ (Body Costume) (first appears in Season 2) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

E.G. Daily

as BJ (Voice) (first appears in Season 2) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)

Debi Derryberry

as BJ (Voice) (first appears in Season 2) in Barney & Friends Fanmade First Generation Cast (What if: Nick Jr. 2012-2016)