Suggestions by @ringothedrummer

Sterling K. Brown

as Aaron Burr in Hamilton

Oscar Isaac

as Alexander Hamilton in Hamilton

Penn Badgley

as The Killer in Gotham (Season Two)

Spoiler

as The Killer in Gotham (Season Two)

Keri Russell

as Martha Wayne in Gotham (Season Two)

Matthew Rhys

as Thomas Wayne in Gotham (Season Two)

Robert Duvall

as Vincent Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Carmine Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Jon Bernthal

as Salvatore Maroni in Gotham (Season Two)

Betsy Brandt

as Louisa Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Jaeden Martell

as Alberto Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Emily Alyn Lind

as Sofia Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Anthony Ippolito

as Mario Falcone in Gotham (Season Two)

Bruce Greenwood

as Gillian Loeb in Gotham (Season Two)

Mahershala Ali

as Christopher Dent in Gotham (Season Two)

Timothy Olyphant

as Joseph "Joe Chill" Chilton in Gotham (Season Two)

Fionn Whitehead

as Stanley Merkel in Gotham (Season Two)

Vera Farmiga

as Leslie Thompkins in Gotham (Season Two)

Chosen Jacobs

as Waylon Jones in Gotham (Season Two)

Barkhad Abdi

as Victor Zsasz in Gotham (Season Two)