Suggestions by @ringothedrummer

Lexi Rabe

as Astra Logue in Hellblazer

Andrew Koji

as John Constantine in Hellblazer

Antonio Banderas

as Thomas Curry in Aquaman

Andrew Koji

as “The Man in a Trench Coat” in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Spoiler

as “The Man in a Trench Coat” in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Richard Kind

as Quincy Sharp in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Denis Ménochet

as Tweedledum and Tweedledee in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Noah Taylor

as The Mad Hatter in Batman: Arkham Asylum

David Cronenberg

as Maxie Zeus in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Benny Safdie

as The Riddler in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Maya Hawke

as Poison Ivy in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Dane DeHaan

as The Scarecrow in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Shea Whigham

as Jack Drake in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Mason Thames

as Robin in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Nico Parker

as Batgirl in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Louis Partridge

as Nightwing in Batman: Arkham Asylum

Mustafa Shakir

as Killer Croc in Batman: Arkham Asylum

David Thewlis

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Arkham Asylum

David Oyelowo

as Lucius Fox in Batman: Arkham Asylum

John C. Reilly

as Jim Gordon in Batman: Arkham Asylum