Suggestions by @ricknee4ever

Nina Dobrev

as Susan Madsen in Melrose Place (2012-2019)

Ashley Greene

as Susan Madsen in Melrose Place (2012-2019)

Jennifer Lopez

as Nia (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Danielle Panabaker

as Chelsea (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Nikki Cox

as Chelsea (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Jessica Alba

as Nia (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Nia (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Sophia Bush

as Chelsea (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Robin Tunney

as Nia (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Rachel Blanchard

as Kennedy (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Ethan Embry

as Hudson (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as River (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Texas Battle

as Sutton (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Jennifer Love Hewitt

as Chelsea (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Usher

as Sutton (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Sara Paxton

as Delancey (2000s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Gabrielle Union

as Madison (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Christina Applegate

as Kenzie (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Nicole Bilderback

as Nolee (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Delancey (90s) in My Scene (90s and 2000s Live Action)