Suggestions by @ricknee4ever

Rick (Happily N'Ever After)

as Ricknee 4Ever in MyCast Users' Fictional Crushes

Cameron Diaz

as Fancy Crane in What Character Do You Want to See Cameron Diaz Play in the 90s

Cameron Diaz

as Gwen Stacy in What Character Do You Want to See Cameron Diaz Play in the 90s

Zac Efron

as Riley Finn in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Ethan Winthrop in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Scott Tracy in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Jeffy in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Caleb in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Peter Parker in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Robin in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Gary Johnston in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Cody in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Brandon in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Tyler Hanson in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as James Harris in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Billy Cranston in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Conrad Jarrett in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Ted Hoover in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Xander McCormick in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s

Zac Efron

as Calvin O'Keefe in What Character Do You Want to See Zac Efron Play in the 2000s