Suggestions by @ richardgrace

Liam Neeson

as Jaga in ThunderCats

Liam Neeson

as Ak in The Life and Adventures of Santa Clause

George Newbern

as Dionysus in The Olympians

Nonso Anozie

as Fezzik in The Princess Bride

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Orlando in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Orladno in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Johnny Depp

as Dr. Chumley in Harvey

Jane Lynch

as Mrs. Packard in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

Mark Ruffalo

as Vinny in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+1-3Score: -2

Brad Pitt

as Commander Lyle Tiberius Rourke in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+1-5Score: -4

Martin Short

as Preston Whitmore in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

Auli'i Cravalho

as Audrey in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+1-3Score: -2

Jenna Ortega

as Audrey in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+2-3Score: -1

Sarah Jeffery

as Princess Kida in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+2-6Score: -4

Toby Jones

as Mole in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

Morgan Freeman

as King Kashekim in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+1-3Score: -2

Jeff Bridges

as Cookie in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

Mike Colter

as Dr. Sweet in Atlantis: The Lost Empire

+4-5Score: -1

Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson

as Mr. Edward Hyde in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen