Suggestions by @ratjesus

Brennan Lee Mulligan

as Cricket in Neverafter

Djimon Hounsou

as Aesop in Neverafter

Idris Elba

as Big Bad Wolf in Neverafter

Noor Taher

as Scheherazade in Neverafter

Natasha Liu Bordizzo

as Snow White in Neverafter

Lovie Simone

as Cinderella in Neverafter

Beanie Feldstein

as Princess Elody of Greenleigh in Neverafter

Donald Glover

as Prince Gerard of Greenleigh in Neverafter

Ella Purnell

as Princess Rosamund du Prix in Neverafter

Charlie Day

as Alphonse in Neverafter

Zac Oyama

as Puss in Boots in Neverafter

Jalyn Hall

as Pinocchio in Neverafter

Abby Ryder Fortson

as Ylfa Snorgelsson in Neverafter

Ian McKellen

as Mother Timothy Goose in Neverafter

Sadie Sink

as Ashlyn in School Bus Graveyard webtoon

Andrew Garfield

as Andrew Garfield in Bojack Horseman

Daniel Radcliffe

as Daniel Radcliffe in Bojack Horseman

Ben Schwartz

as Rutabaga Rabitowitz in Bojack Horseman

Nathan Fillion

as Meow Meow Fuzzyface in Bojack Horseman

William Jackson Harper

as Wayne in Bojack Horseman