Suggestions by @pikachu2342
1,762 suggestions
Hugh Jackman
as Azazel in Supernatural
Jack Black
as Metatron in Supernatural
Chase Stokes
as Gadreel in Supernatural
Matthew McConaughey
as Dick Roman in Supernatural
Laura Harrier
as Patience Turner in Supernatural
Sabrina Carpenter
as Claire Novak in Supernatural
Natalie Portman
as Jody Mills in Supernatural
Robert Pattinson
as Mick in Supernatural
Felicity Jones
as Jessica Moore in Supernatural
Samuel L. Jackson
as Victor Hendrikson in Supernatural
KJ Apa
as Garth in Supernatural
Elle Fanning
as Jo in Supernatural
Cate Blanchett
as Ellen in Supernatural
Jack Dylan Grazer
as Ben in Supernatural
Emma Watson
as Lisa in Supernatural
Andy Serkis
as Benny in Supernatural
Daisy Ridley
as Bela Talbot in Supernatural
Michael B. Jordan
as Gordon Walker in Supernatural
Chris Hemsworth
as Balthazar in Supernatural
Kristen Stewart
as Meg in Supernatural