Suggestions by @paulcoolman

Sebastian Stan

as Sam Trapani in Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven

John Goodman

as Don Salieri in Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven

James McAvoy

as Tommy Angelo in Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven

Jonah Hill

as Joey in Raging bull

Jack Nicholson

as Carlo Falcone in Per Aspera Ad Astra (1980)

Martin Sheen

as Henry Tomasino in Per Aspera Ad Astra (1980)

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Luca Gurino in Mafia II

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Older Marlon Brando in Marlon Brando Biopic

John David Washington

as Robert Neville in I Am Legend (2021)

Frank Crudele

as El Greco in Mafia II

Jason O'Mara

as Brian O'Niell in Mafia II

Richard Gere

as Tommy Angelo (protagonist) in Mafia (1982)

Will Smith

as Lincoln clay in Mafia 3 (1996)

Andy Garcia

as Vito Scaletta (protagonist) in Mafia 2 (1988)

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Neil McCauley in Heat (2021)

Henry Cavill

as Henry Tomasino in Mafia II

Marion Cotillard

as Francesca Scaletta in Mafia II

Josh Safdie

as Producer in Disco Scene

Paul Thomas Anderson

as Director in Disco Scene

Bradley Cooper

as Anthony Langella in Disco Scene