Suggestions by @paulcoolman

James Spader

as The Phantasm in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Annabelle Wallis

as Kay Adams in The Family Corleone: The Godfather Part II.V

Anne Hathaway

as Andrea Beaumont in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Annabelle Wallis

as Kay in The Godfather (2022)

John Carroll Lynch

as Alfred Stryker in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Sebastian Stan

as Henry Hill in Goodfellas (2015)

Michael Pitt

as The Joker in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Paul Thomas Anderson

as Writer in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Christopher Nolan

as Producer in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

David Fincher

as Director in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Josh Brolin

as Carl Beaumont in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

J.K. Simmons

as Salvatore Valestra in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Steve Buscemi

as Salvatore Valestra in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Bobby Cannavale

as Salvatore Maroni in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Shea Whigham

as Harvey Bullock in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Ian McKellen

as Alfred Pennyworth in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Ryan Gosling

as Arthur Reeves in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner Jim Gordon in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Jon Hamm

as Harvey Dent in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)

Scarlett Johansson

as Andrea Beaumont in Gotham Noire Part II (2013)