Suggestions by @parkerjohnson
193 suggestions

Hailee Steinfeld
as Lúthien Tinúviel in The Silmarillion

Ian McKellen
as OLÓRIN in The Silmarillion

Katheryn Winnick
as Freya in Zack Snyder's God of War

Kathryn Hahn
as Freya in Zack Snyder's God of War

Seth Rogen
as Actor in Least Popular/ Worst Actor in the World

Maisie Williams
as Sophie Turner in Actors who should play love interests to other actors

Travis Fimmel
as Jack Sparrow in Recasting Famous Roles

Evanna Lynch
as Anne Bonny in Notorious Thieves: A Pirates HBO Series

Evanna Lynch
as Anne Bonny in Sea Dogs

Robert Englund
as The Scarecrow in The Batman 2 & 3

Thomasin McKenzie
as Padmé Amidala in Star Wars Prequel Trilogy (2019-2025)

Haley Bennett
as Sarene in Elantris

Haley Bennett
as Princess Sarene in Elantris

Shailene Woodley
as Mary Jane Watson in The Amazing Spider-Man 3
Ansel Elgort
as Vicomte Raoul de Chagny in The Phantom of the Opera

Daveed Diggs
as Hobbes in Calvin and Hobbes

Timothy Dalton
as Aslan in The Chronicles of Narnia Series (2022~)

Dafne Keen
as Vin in Cosmere

Timothy Dalton
as Aslan in Chronicles of Narnia (TV Series)

Malina Weissman
as Susan Pevensie in Chronicles of Narnia (TV Series)