Suggestions by @oldchatot
1,184 suggestions
Ioan Gruffudd
as Fëanor in The Silmarillion
Sam Retford
as Dior in The Silmarillion
Paris Jackson
as Elwing in The Silmarillion
Vanessa Kirby
as Elwing in The Silmarillion
Sam Heughan
as Eärendil in The Silmarillion
Margaret Qualley
as Lúthien in The Silmarillion
Elle Fanning
as Lúthien in The Silmarillion
Charlize Theron
as Melian in The Silmarillion
Anne Hathaway
as Melian in The Silmarillion
Gustaf Skarsgård
as Olwë in The Silmarillion
Alexander Skarsgård
as Olwë in The Silmarillion
Alexander Skarsgård
as Elwë in The Silmarillion
James D'Arcy
as Elwë in The Silmarillion
Gustaf Skarsgård
as Elwë in The Silmarillion
Morgan Freeman
as Eru Ilúvatar in The Silmarillion
Liam Neeson
as Eru Ilúvatar in The Silmarillion
Jodie Comer
as Celebrían in The Silmarillion
Claire Holt
as Celebrían in The Silmarillion
Harry Greenwood
as Elrond in The Silmarillion
Will Poulter
as Elrond in The Silmarillion