Suggestions by @nosetwice

Mr. Arrow (Treasure Planet)

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Captain Gantu

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Moxxie (Helluva Boss)

as Charlie Day in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Yar (Dinosaur)

as Samuel L. Jackson in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Rothbart

as Jim Carrey in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Balto (Character)

as Ryan Reynolds in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Grandpa Longneck

as Jim Cummings in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Scroop (Treasure Planet)

as Bill Skarsgård in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

Tuke (Brother Bear)

as Seth Rogen in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

Tara Strong

as Alan Keane in The Amazing World of Gumball (Live-action/computer-animated film)

Grey DeLisle

as Carmen in The Amazing World of Gumball

Tara Strong

as Alan Keane in The Amazing World of Gumball

Cyborg (Teen Titans Go!)

as Eddie Murphy in Actor face claims by characters they've played or will play

The Chameleon (Kung Fu Panda)

as Viola Davis in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Larry (The Wild)

as Richard Kind in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Professor Pee-Pee Diarrheastein Poopypants Esq. (Tippy Tinkletrousers)

as Nick Kroll in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Grandpa Longneck

as Kenneth Mars in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Alan Keane

as Tara Strong in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Twilight Sparkle

as Tara Strong in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Tantoo Cardinal

as Tanana in Disney Brother Bear Live Action