Suggestions by @nitrogencake

Richard Gere

as Clinton Greene in The Last of Sheila (2003)

Ian McShane

as Philip Dexter in The Last of Sheila (2003)

Sarah Connor

as Margot Robbie in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Frank Reynolds

as Ray Liotta in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Robin Hood (Disney Character)

as Bernard Fox in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Robin Hood (Disney Character)

as Tommy Steele in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

The Riddler (Edward Nigma)

as Steve Martin in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

The Riddler (Edward Nigma)

as Phil Hartman in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

The Riddler (Edward Nigma)

as Matthew Broderick in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

The Riddler (Edward Nigma)

as Kelsey Grammer in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Daxter

as Chris Rock in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

John Nada (They Live!)

as Arnold Schwarzenegger in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Sam Reid in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Taylor Kitsch in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Thomas Cocquerel in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Nicholas Hoult in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Wilson Bethel in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kyle Reese

as Garrett Hedlund in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Todd Alquist

as Robin Lord Taylor in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Jesse Pinkman

as Reid Scott in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted