Suggestions by @newclearstar
2,825 suggestions
Skeet Ulrich
as Jimmy Mance in Harper's Island (1992)
Sean William Scott
as Christopher "Sully" Sullivan in Harper's Island (1992)
Jorge Garcia
as Malcolm Ross in Harper's Island (1992)
Adrian Grenier
as Shane Pierce in Harper's Island (1992)
Sean Maguire
as Cal Vandeusen in Harper's Island (1992)
Claire Danes
as Beth Barrington in Harper's Island (1992)
Edward Norton
as Richard Allen in Harper's Island (1992)
Patricia Arquette
as Lucy Daramour in Harper's Island (1992)
Michael Douglas
as Thomas Wellington in Harper's Island (1992)
Daniel Day-Lewis
as Henry Dunn in Harper's Island (1992)
Debbie Harry
as Katherine Wellington in Harper's Island (1992)
Fairuza Balk
as Kelly Seaver in Harper's Island (1992)
Mark Wahlberg
as Hunter Jennings in Harper's Island (1992)
Maggie Gyllenhaal
as Shea Allen in Harper's Island (1992)
Christina Ricci
as Madison Allen in Harper's Island (1992)
Anjelica Huston
as Maggie Krell in Harper's Island (1992)
Laura Linney
as Chloe Carter in Harper's Island (1992)
Hilary Swank
as Patricia 'Trish' Wellington in Harper's Island (1992)
Winona Ryder
as Abby Mills in Harper's Island (1992)
Don Johnson
as "Uncle" Marty Dunn in Harper's Island (1992)