Suggestions by @nellie23

Kelli O'Hara

as Sarah Brown in Guys And Dolls

Jeremy Jordan

as Sky Masterson in Guys And Dolls

Jonathan Majors

as Coalhouse Walker Jr. in Ragtime

Alan Cumming

as Harry Houdini in Ragtime

Jonathan Groff

as Mother's Youngest Brother in Ragtime

Josh Groban

as Tateh in Ragtime

Annaleigh Ashford

as Evelyn Nesbit in Ragtime

Alan Cumming

as Zoser in Aida

Tinashe

as Deena Jones in Dreamgirls

Adrienne Warren

as Lorrell Robinson in Dreamgirls

Jacob Tremblay

as Edgar in Ragtime

Emily Blunt

as Diana in Next to Normal

Steven Spielberg

as Director in Ragtime

Kate Winslet

as Emma Goldman in Ragtime

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Tateh in Ragtime

Michelle Williams

as Mother in Ragtime

Anika Noni Rose

as Sarah in Ragtime

Neil Patrick Harris

as Mother's Youngest Brother in Ragtime

Anika Noni Rose

as Aida in Aida

Christiana Danielle

as Aida in Aida