Suggestions by @nathanielpreston
14,957 suggestions
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Best Catwoman in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Robert Englund
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
John Glover
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Wally Wingert
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Jim Carrey
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Cory Michael Smith
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Frank Gorshin
as Best Riddler in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Brad Pitt
as Worst Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Nicolas Cage
as Worst Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Jim Carrey
as Worst Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Harrison Ford
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Emily Blunt
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Jodie Foster
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Hugh Jackman
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Alec Baldwin
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
John Lithgow
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Bob Hoskins
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Brad Dourif
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings
Mel Gibson
as Best Almost Cast in Best & Worst Superhero Castings