Suggestions by @mistquill

Donna Murphy

as Helen of Troy in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Sienna Guillory

as Helen of Troy in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Maggie Smith

as Cleopatra in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Maggie Smith

as Elizabeth Woodville in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

James Howson

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Robert Cavanah

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Cliff Richard

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Ralph Fiennes

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Timothy Dalton

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Richard Burton

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Laurence Olivier

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Jacob Elordi

as Heathcliff in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Yvonne Mitchell

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Ann Trevor

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Merle Oberon

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Katharine Blake

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Angela Scoular

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Juliette Binoche

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Orla Brady

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Charlotte Riley

as Catherine Earnshaw in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters