Suggestions by @mishafitt

Sherri Saum

as Calla Johnson in The Raven Cycle

Lucas Till

as Evan Fine in Heart

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Lili Ardat in Heart

Gwyneth Paltrow

as Amber Cass in Heart

Vanessa Williams

as Silvia in The Selection Series

Caitlin Carver

as Celeste in The Selection Series

Gage Golightly

as Marlee in The Selection Series

Amber Midthunder

as Mare in Red Queen Series

Kristin Bauer

as Queen Elara in Red Queen Series

Rhiannon Fish

as Mare in Red Queen Series

Halston Sage

as Evangeline in Red Queen Series

Richard Harmon

as Maven in Red Queen Series

McKaley Miller

as Mackenzie in The Perfectionists

Soma Bhatia

as Ava in The Perfectionists

Ellie Bamber

as Julie in The Perfectionists

Maika Monroe

as Parker in The Perfectionists

Kalinka Pétrie

as Leandra in Bliss

Shay Mitchell

as Sophia in Bliss

Ansel Elgort

as Atlas Fuller in The Thousandth Floor Series

Bianca A. Santos

as Mariel Valconsuelos in The Thousandth Floor Series