Suggestions by @misanawylie

Andrew McCarthy

as Franklin Pierce in Presidents Biopic Films

Tom Brady

as John Kennedy in Presidents Biopic Films

Jessica Alba

as Edith Roosevelt in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

David Harbour

as Presley M. Rixey in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Bruce Willis

as Mark Hanna in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Jack Black

as William McKinley in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Russell Wilson

as James Benjamin Parker in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Matt LeBlanc

as William McKinley in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Annie Potts

as Ida McKinley in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley

Helena Bonham Carter

as Ida McKinley in American Crime Story: The Assassination of William McKinley